April 15th, 2009
The 56th edition of Wine Blogging Wednesday, the monthly themed wine tasting, now over 4 years in the making, is a subject near and dear to my heart. This month’s theme, hosted by The Corkdork, is kosher wines.
Until a year and a half ago, I hadn’t had much kosher wine. At our Passover seders, my Dad brings the wine and we drink anything he’s excited to share, kosher or not. Religion has its place at certain holidays, but most of the time we are a pretty secular family.
It wasn’t until I met a special person who I fondly refer to as “E” on this site, that I discovered more than I ever needed to know about kosher wine. In our first phone conversation in fact, I asked the same silly question that most people ask about kosher wine: “What does it have to be, like, blessed by a Rabbi, or something?” After some time I learned the realities of kosher wine. Yes, some kosher wines suck, but some really deserve our respect.
There are two types of kosher wine: mevushal and non-mevushal. A mevushal wine is heated during the winemaking process to 185°. The explanation for this is complex, but let’s just say it has ancient roots in religious ritual. With flash pasteurization, the process is less damaging, but it’s hardly beneficial. There are some good kosher wines that are mevushal, but it’s this process that gives kosher wine a bad rep. People often ask: “Kosher wine? don’t they boil it until it’s devoid of taste?”
A mevushal wine can be handled by anybody while a non-mevushal wine must be made by Sabbath-observing Jews for the entire process. So, despite my Jewish heritage, I could not make a non-mevushal wine. I’m not Jewish enough! I’m sure you can imagine how difficult it is to find (and pay) a bevy of observant Jews to handle the entire winemaking process which makes non-mevushal wines not only rare, but expensive. These are some of the best kosher wines.
Whether mevushal or not, kosher wine can only be made with kosher ingredients and it will have a little K or U symbol to designate its status.

I was out in Borough Park, Brooklyn with E last Sunday for a Sheva Brachat (post-wedding ceremony) and we stopped in at a wine shop around the corner called, The Winery. My favorite Kosher wine (Domaine du Castel 2005 Grand Vin) is a Bordeaux blend from Judean Hills so I thought it would be a wise choice to select something else from the region.
I tasted two wines from a producer called Katlav, located Southwest of Jerusalem in the Judean Hills.
Katlav, Wadi Katlav 2005 (60% Cabernet Sauvignon, 30% Merlot, 10% Shiraz), Judean Hills, 14.5% alc, Kosher, Non-Mevushal: Huge on the nose with pronounced cherry, plum, baking spice, and cedar notes. The alcohol is a little sharp. On the palate it’s rich and full-bodied with lingering, juicy dark fruit. The tannins were a bit soft for such tremendous fruit. A little too extracted for my taste though the finish is balanced and it has a pleasant, long length. E was more fond of it than me which is shocking because he prefers a more rustic, softer fruit style. Good, but worth $50? Not really.
Katlav Merlot 2005, Judean Hills, 14.5% Alc, Kosher, Non-Mevushal: More subtle on the nose than the Wadi Katlav but still displaying nice aromas of plum with some strawberry, hints of oak and vanilla. On the palate it’s medium-bodied with similar plum notes and hints of clove. It’s less complex than the Wadi Katlav but I enjoyed it more, the fruit was balanced by firm tannins that made it a pleasure to drink.
Both of these wines, though good quality and drinkable, were overpriced compared to non-kosher wines of the same caliber. They both were $50 which is a price I’d pay for something incredible. There is definitely great kosher wine to be had, but as I’ve often found, it commands a hefty price tag.
It’s a tragic irony really, that kosher wine has taken so long to have a revolution in quality. Wine is an integral part of Judaism. Nearly all of our holidays include a blessing over wine, including the weekly holiday of Shabbat (which opens and closes with a cup of wine). Many holidays like Passover even command that you drink multiple cups of wine. On Passover we drink 4 per meal! I hope that more folks this Passover branched out and experimented with wines made from something other than Concord grapes.
It can be tough to find a good kosher wine, but they’re out there! Thanks to The Corkdork for hosting this theme! I’m looking forward to reading what everyone finds.
Pssst, Many of the recipes here are kosher. Here some favorites if you’d like to make a kosher meal with your newly discovered kosher wine:
Roasted Honey Chicken Stuffed with Garlic
Roasted Lamb with Charmoula
Vietnamese Style Steak Salad
Sesame-Pepper Crusted Tuna with Soba Noodles
Roasted Bone Marrow with Parsley Salad
Arctic Char with Eggplant, Pesto and Dijon Aioli
Filed under , Wine Blogging Wednesday | Comments (2)